A Civic Media radio station

Civic Media Logo
Environmental lawyer: CAFOs not just a NIMBY issue

Source: Canva

Environmental lawyer: CAFOs not just a NIMBY issue

Wisconsin currently has nearly 340 concentrated animal feeding operations.

May 7, 2024 1:27 PM CDT

By: Mike Moen / Wisconsin News Connection

STEVENS POINT, Wis. (Wisconsin News Connection) – The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources has a month to respond in court to a new lawsuit concerning a factory farm in the central part of the state.

Those leading the legal fight said the case speaks to how worried some communities are about concentrated animal feeding operations.

Across the nation, there’s been plenty of debate and legal action over the growth of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs). Those fighting a Wisconsin operation say it’s not just about residents being generally opposed, but rather protecting vital natural resources from being overly contaminated.

The group Midwest Environmental Advocates represents Portage County residents in a lawsuit claiming the Department of Natural Resources reached an illegal settlement with a large livestock facility for a wastewater permit. At issue is whether the state should have allowed public input.

Adam Voskuil, staff attorney for the group, said as concentrated animal feeding operations gain a bigger footprint, data is becoming clear about the harm to local resources.

“We’re seeing concerns over CAFOs in western Wisconsin, too, where there have been significant spills and fish kills,” Voskuil reported.

He is referring to a 2019 incident where a settlement was reached with a large dairy operation over a manure discharge. For his clients, Voskuil pointed to 2018 county data showing elevated nitrate levels in private wells, saying it rises above the traditional “not-in-my-backyard” opposition.

The DNR would not comment on the lawsuit but some farm groups say large ag facilities have to adhere to strict regulations as they help feed the world.

Voskuil noted people who live near the sites are not regulators. They are individuals asking for responses to what they feel is a growing crisis.

“I really think that we need to stop just accepting that CAFOs can externalize the cost of environmental contamination onto the communities that live downstream or downwind,” Voskuil stressed.

Wisconsin currently has nearly 340 concentrated animal feeding operations as consolidation in agriculture outmuscles smaller, independent farms.

Even though the DNR is targeted in the new lawsuit, the agency was being defended by the state in a separate case for maintaining the permitting process for the projects. The suit was brought by industry groups who said they are being overregulated.

This article originally appeared on Wisconsin News Connection, a division of Public News Service.

More Articles

  • New legislative districts in NW Wisconsin give Dems a better chance in 2024, experts say

    5/17/2024 | Hina Suzuki / The Badger Project

    A Tyrannosaurus Rex took a big blue bite out of the 73rd Assembly District in Douglas County and spit it into the neighboring district. That’s how some commenters described the change to the 73rd after Republicans redrew it before the 2022 election. The GOP swapped those bluer areas with rural, Republican-leaning parts of Burnett County […]

  • New, compacted political maps in Marathon County boot long-time legislator from old district

    5/17/2024 | Hina Suzuki / The Badger Project

    The new maps separated the towns of Schofield and Rothschild from the new 85th District and put them into the 87th.

  • Oldest UWM Honors College Graduate

    5/17/2024

    A former Richland Center resident has found herself in a prestigious minority. JoAnne Potter, 72 of Milwaukee, is graduating with a bachelor’s degree at UW-Milwaukee. After living in Richland Center for more than 20 years, JoAnne moved back to Milwaukee in 2020. After getting settled, in 2022 she decided to go back to college to […]

  • 8th Congressional District to have 2 elections on fall ballots

    5/17/2024 | Lisa M. Hale

    Two elections for the 8th Congressional District will be on the same ballot and the Wisconsin Elections Commission (WEC) is trying to find a way to explain the elections to avoid voter confusion.

  • Pianos + Art + Music equals Keys to the City

    5/17/2024 | Lisa M. Hale

    This weekend a unique live art and music festival will take to public locations throughout the Green Bay community. The Keys to the City Painted Piano Festival features music from local artists, donated pianos, live art by area artists, and culminates in the unveiling of five new, interactive art installations throughout the city.

image
WAUK - Waukesha - The 'SHA